Pryce, by contrast, is all earthy motion. His Bergoglio shuffles, sighs, and dances the tango in his head. He is a pope who smells of sheep, who washes the feet of the poor, and who speaks of God not in Latin syllogisms but in the silence of a rainy Buenos Aires street.
This levity is not disrespectful; it is radical. The film argues that the sacred is found in the profane. When Francis later sneaks out of the Vatican to minister to the homeless or when Benedict quietly slips away into retirement, the film celebrates the small, rebellious acts of humanity. los dos papas
Released on Netflix to critical acclaim, the film arrived at a moment when the real-world Catholic Church was fracturing between reactionary traditionalists and reformists. By focusing on the transition from Pope Benedict XVI to Pope Francis, Los Dos Papas does not just document a historical handover; it invents a spiritual thriller where the only weapons are guilt, confession, and the Sistine Chapel’s floor tiles. The film’s engine is its casting. Anthony Hopkins as Joseph Ratzinger (Pope Benedict XVI) and Jonathan Pryce as Jorge Mario Bergoglio (Pope Francis) deliver masterclasses in internal conflict. Hopkins plays Benedict not as a villain, but as a lonely scholar. His Ratzinger is a man who loves the Church as an abstract, perfect architecture of doctrine. He is rigid, brilliant, and terrified of the mob. When he plays the piano in the papal summer residence, he looks less like a pontiff and more like a retired professor who has outlived his century. Pryce, by contrast, is all earthy motion
The film constructs a fictionalized private meeting in 2012 at Castel Gandolfo, where Bergoglio—having already attempted to resign as archbishop—is summoned by Benedict to discuss his departure. This meeting never happened in real life, but Meirelles and screenwriter Anthony McCarten use this dramatic license to stage a series of philosophical duels. The film’s most audacious scene occurs in the Sistine Chapel, beneath the gaze of Michelangelo’s The Last Judgment . Here, Bergoglio confesses his sins to the Pope. It is a stunning inversion of power: the future pope confessing to the current pope. But the scene is not about absolution; it is about revelation. This levity is not disrespectful; it is radical